Vanished in the Darkness: The Heather Elvis Case

Heather Elvis was a radiant 20-year-old whose infectious spirit and kind heart touched everyone in her Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, community. Born on June 30, 1993, in Horry County, Heather was the beloved eldest daughter of Terry and Debbi Elvis and a devoted sister to Morgan. Her disappearance on December 18, 2013, in the darkness of a winter night, left a community in mourning and sparked a complex investigation into her presumed murder. This blog post celebrates Heather’s vibrant life, her passions, and the unyielding love of her family, while compassionately detailing the tragic events of the Heather Elvis case and the pursuit of justice.

A Life Full of Joy and Promise

Heather Elvis was a young woman with a bright future. As a hostess at the Tilted Kilt, a Celtic-themed pub in Myrtle Beach, she was known for her hard work and warm personality. Friends, including her best friend and roommate Brianna Kulzer, described her as kind, spirited, and a source of light. Heather had recently secured a job at a beauty parlor, a role she was excited to start just before Christmas 2013. She was also reconnecting with her faith, planning to attend church with Brianna, reflecting her desire for a fresh start.

Heather’s social media posts revealed her lively personality. She shared her love for music, humor, and life’s small joys, like learning to drive a stick shift during a date—a moment she texted to her father, Terry, on the night she vanished. One of her final Twitter posts, a retweet of a Daniel Tosh joke about relationships, carried a haunting irony: “hey married fellas, you can either cheat on your wife OR murder her. never both. that’s when you get caught.”

Above all, Heather was a devoted daughter and sister. Her close bond with Terry, Debbi, and Morgan anchored her life. The Elvis family’s love has fueled their relentless advocacy, transforming their grief into a mission to keep Heather’s memory alive and seek justice in the Heather Elvis case.

The Night Heather Vanished in the Darkness

On December 17, 2013, Heather went on a first date with Steven Schiraldi, hoping to move on from a turbulent affair with Sidney Moorer, a 37-year-old married maintenance worker she met at the Tilted Kilt. The date ended around 1:15 a.m. on December 18, when Steven dropped her off at her Carolina Forest apartment. Heather texted her father a photo of herself learning to drive a stick shift, a joyful moment that became their last exchange. Around 1:44 a.m., she called Brianna, who was visiting family, to discuss the date. During the call, Heather was upset, revealing that Sidney had contacted her from a payphone, rekindling old emotions. Brianna advised her to rest and avoid rash decisions.

Phone records show Heather received a call from a payphone at 1:35 a.m., later admitted to by Sidney Moorer, and she tried calling it back nine times. Her cell phone activity stopped around 6 a.m., and she has not been seen since. On December 19, her green Dodge Intrepid was found abandoned at Peachtree Landing, a boat ramp on the Waccamaw River in Socastee. The car was locked, containing her driver’s license and business cards, but her purse and phone were missing, with no signs of a struggle. The discovery marked the beginning of the Heather Elvis disappearance case, a mystery that gripped Myrtle Beach.

The Investigation: Unraveling a Web of Deception

The investigation into the Heather Elvis case quickly centered on Sidney Moorer and his wife, Tammy Moorer. Heather’s affair with Sidney, which began in June 2013, ended in October when Tammy discovered it. Tammy’s response was a barrage of harassment, including threatening texts, explicit photos of herself with Sidney, and attempts to get Heather fired by repeatedly calling the Tilted Kilt. She allegedly handcuffed Sidney to the bed at night and monitored his movements to prevent further contact with Heather.

Critical evidence emerged:

Phone Records: Sidney’s 1:35 a.m. payphone call to Heather, initially denied but later admitted, was a key focus. Heather’s repeated calls back to the payphone suggested she was lured to a meeting.

Surveillance Footage: A grainy video placed Sidney’s Ford F-150 near Peachtree Landing on the night of the disappearance, contradicting his alibi. Footage from the Moorers’ home showed Sidney cleaning his truck, with the security system disabled only that night.

Motive Speculation: Rumors of Heather’s possible pregnancy, potentially with Sidney’s child, surfaced after she gained weight and a pregnancy test at work showed an “error.” Prosecutors suggested this fueled Tammy’s jealousy. Sidney was seen buying a pregnancy test that night.

Disturbing Testimony: A cousin of Tammy’s claimed Sidney showed him a photo of Heather, appearing deceased with blood and scratches, though this was not pursued further in court.

In February 2014, Sidney and Tammy Moorer were arrested and charged with murder, kidnapping, and obstruction of justice. The murder charges were dropped in March 2016 due to the absence of Heather’s body, but kidnapping charges persisted, keeping the Heather Elvis murder case alive.

Trials and the Fight for Justice

Tammy Moorer’s October 2018 trial painted her as a jealous, controlling figure, described by prosecutors as an “Evil Queen” driven by rage over Heather’s affair with Sidney. After an 11-day trial, she was convicted of kidnapping and conspiracy to kidnap, receiving a 30-year sentence. Sidney’s 2016 kidnapping trial ended in a hung jury, but he was convicted of obstruction of justice in 2017 (10 years) and kidnapping in September 2019 (30 years). Both are serving their sentences, with appeals denied as of June 2023.

Despite convictions, Heather’s body remains missing, denying her family closure. The lack of physical evidence—no blood, no murder weapon—posed challenges, but prosecutors argued Sidney lured Heather to Peachtree Landing, where she was kidnapped and likely killed in the Heather Elvis murder case.

The Elvis Family’s Grief and Strength

The Heather Elvis disappearance has left an enduring wound on her family. Terry and Debbi Elvis have spoken of their relentless pain, with Debbi saying, “I wake up every morning and that’s the first thing I think of.” Morgan, Heather’s younger sister, lamented that Heather has become “a face on a poster” rather than a person with a vibrant life. The family endured further anguish from online harassment and conspiracy theories, some spread by the Moorers, who portrayed Heather as a stalker.

The Elvises have transformed their grief into advocacy. They host vigils at Peachtree Landing and raise awareness for other missing persons cases in Horry County. On Heather’s 30th birthday in 2023, they hung posters for missing individuals, emphasizing community support. Terry’s memory of opening Heather’s car trunk, fearing the worst, reflects their ongoing trauma. Yet, their hope endures, with Debbi stating, “I need to find Heather.”

Vigils, like the one on December 18, 2023, marking the 10th anniversary of Heather’s disappearance, allow the community to honor her. Family friend Tammy Britt and Brianna Kulzer, now a firefighter, joined the Elvises to light lanterns and share memories, keeping Heather’s spirit alive.

Heather Elvis’s Legacy: A Call to Remember

Heather Elvis was more than a true crime case—she was a young woman with dreams, a loving daughter, and a friend who radiated kindness. Her story, featured in Vanished: The Heather Elvis Case (2025) and 20/20 episodes, underscores the devastating impact of jealousy and betrayal. Yet, her family’s resilience defines her legacy. Terry, Debbi, and Morgan continue to seek answers, ensuring Heather is remembered as a person, not just a mystery.

To honor Heather:

1. Listen to Heather’s story, covered on Dark Dialogue. It can be listed to everyplace you get podcasts, or on the player below.
2. Support Missing Persons Causes: Contribute to organizations like the CUE Center for Missing Persons, which aided in Heather’s search.
3. Learn Her Story: Watch Vanished: The Heather Elvis Case or read accounts on WBTW and The Post and Courier.
4. Spread Kindness: Reflect Heather’s warmth by supporting your community, as her family does through advocacy.
5. Stay Informed: Follow updates on true crime on this website. We will post updates as they become available.
6. Like and follow us at our social media links below.
7. Support our focus on victims of true crime and their families on Ko-fi at the link below.
8. Become a monthly subscriber at the Ko-fi at the link below to take advantage of all the membership benefits!

Heather’s light shines through her family’s love and the Myrtle Beach community’s solidarity. May her memory inspire compassion and may the Elvis family find the answers they seek in the darkness of her vanishing.